Why 20% Of Donors Often Drive 80% Of Your Fundraising
For many nonprofit leaders, this pattern is probably familiar; you open your annual fundraising report and most of your donations are coming from just a handful of people. At first it might feel concerning that you don’t have a larger pool of donors, but this is a very common pattern and it’s known as the Pareto Principle, or the 80/20 rule. It suggests that for many situations, about 80% of the results come from just 20% of the effort. In fundraising, this means a small segment of your donors—your major givers often contribute to the majority of your funds. Recognizing why this occurs and identifying these donors allows you to concentrate your resources where they’ll deliver the greatest return. In this post, learn about the 80/20 rule in fundraising, what drives major donors, and how to engage them.
Pareto Principle Example
The 80/20 rule was first observed by Italian economist Vilfredo Pareto in 1896 when he noticed that 80% of the land in Italy was owned by just 20% of the population. Since then, this principle has been found in nearly every field from business to software.
For nonprofits, it highlights that while every donor is valuable, not all donations are equal in their financial impact. Acknowledging this allows you to allocate your limited time, resources, and energy more effectively. Instead of treating every donor the same, you can develop a focused approach for cultivating the 20% who have the potential to make a transformative impact on your mission.
Understanding Your Top 20% Of Donors
The 20% are often referred to as major donors, but they represent more than their donations. They share distinct characteristics and motivations that differentiate them, and recognizing the psychology behind their giving is key to cultivating strong, enduring relationships.
Donors Connection To The Mission
Major donors aren’t just giving money, but they’re investing in something meaningful to them. Their support often grows from lived experience, family values, or a strong belief in the change your organization is working to create. They view their contributions as a partnership in advancing a common goal.
Why Donors Want Both Impact & Information
Major donors want to see tangible results and to know that their contribution is making a real difference. Vague platitudes are not enough. They’re looking for reports, personal updates, and direct evidence of the impact their funds are having. They want to see the "return on investment," not in financial terms, but in lives changed and the advancement of your mission.
The Importance Of Personal Relationships With Donors
Major donors give to people they trust and organizations they believe in. Relationships matter—connections with leaders, board members, and program staff are very important. A generic thank-you email isn’t enough. What they truly value are personal conversations, updates, and opportunities to see the impact of their giving firsthand.
Major Donor Fundraising: How To Engage Your Top 20% Of Donors
Recognizing who your major donors are is only the first step. Developing a strategy to nurture and and grow these relationships will be key. Here’s how to use the 80/20 rule for your nonprofit.
1. Analyze Your Existing Donor Data
Your greatest prospects are usually in your donor database. Consider the below data points to help you analyze patterns that indicate the potential to donate.
Loyalty⎯Who has been giving consistently for years, even if the amounts were small? A long history of giving indicates a strong belief in your mission.
Increased Giving⎯Have any donors recently increased their gift size without being asked? This can signal a change in financial capacity or a deeper commitment to your cause.
Total Giving⎯Identify donors whose cumulative giving over time is significant. They may be willing to make a larger, one-time gift.
2. Prospect Research
Once you have a list of potential major donors, you then need to learn more about them. This is where prospect research comes in. Prospect research involves gathering and analyzing data such as wealth indicators, professional affiliations, and personal connections to the organization. This information helps identify individuals with both the capacity and inclination to give at a major level. This helps nonprofits tailor engagement strategies and build stronger, more meaningful relationships with the donors who are most likely to make a lasting impact.
3. Develop A Strategy To Cultivate Relationships
Major donor fundraising requires patience and personalization. After identifying a prospect, create a tailored plan that includes meaningful, individualized communication, exclusive experiences, and tangible demonstrations of impact so donors know how their contributions will make a real difference.
4. Make Every Major Gift Ask Count
While asking for a significant gift may seem intimidating, a carefully planned approach ensures it is both respectful and impactful. Ways to do this is by involving the right people. The ask to a major donor should be made by a peer or someone high up in the organization like an Executive Director or a board member. Prepare thoroughly and propose a specific, ambitious, yet realistic gift amount related to a project or need.
Strategies For Nurturing Your Donor Base
Focusing on the top 20% doesn't mean neglecting the other 80%⎯this group is the pipeline for your future major donors. Consistent and meaningful engagement with your mid-level and small-dollar donors is crucial for long-term sustainability. Continue to nurture these relationships through targeted newsletters, social media posts, and by events like in-person or silent auctions. A small donor today could become a major donor at any time.
Start Planning Your Nonprofit Fundraiser
Whether you’re planning a school fundraiser or a corporate gala, featuring high-value consignment vacation packages and experiences will get your donor excited, and help you raise more for your mission. Our consignment travel and experience packages come with no financial commitment—you only pay once they’re sold to a bidder, so it’s risk-free. Contact us now to learn more!