What Your Auction Results Can Tell You About Next Year’s Catalog
By Karen Wrege, Founder, Capital Benefit Auctions
Every auction committee has a story about the item that brought down the house. That story is useful. It can also lead a committee to procure five more items just like it, only to discover that one enthusiastic bidder made the difference.
When I review an auction, I want to know what the whole room did. Which items attracted several different bidders? Which sold at the opening bid? Which never sold? And after paying any consignment cost, what did the organization actually keep?
Look Past the Headline Price
Imagine two trips each selling for $4,000. One drew eight bidders and climbed quickly. The other drew one bidder at its opening price. The revenue line looks the same, but the planning lesson is different. The first suggests you may be able to serve again. The second invites questions about the opening bid, dates, description, placement, and whether the experience suited this audience.
I also look at the number of people bidding, not just the number of bids. Two determined guests can create a long bidding history. That is exciting on auction night, but it does not necessarily mean you have a broad market for three similar trips next year.
Then there is the item that never sold. Leaving it out of the analysis makes a category look healthier than it is. If you offered ten travel packages and sold seven, all ten belong in the conversation.
Follow the Pattern Across Years
A single event can be distorted by weather, attendance, a particularly generous bidder, or an unusually strong donation. Results across two or three years are more revealing.
Say local weekend stays repeatedly bring several bidders, while longer international trips close near their minimum. That does not mean your supporters dislike travel. They may prefer a shorter commitment, a more flexible booking window, or a price they can decide on in the room. A good consignment partner can use that information to suggest a better fit.
The same logic applies outside travel. If dining packages sell well but each additional certificate attracts fewer bids, more procurement may produce little extra revenue. If tickets to a local game draw competition while signed memorabilia sits untouched, the category label “sports” hides the real preference.
Turn the Review Into a Decision
My favorite outcome of an analysis is a short, specific assignment for the committee: bring back two flexible weekend experiences, change the opening price on a promising item, test one new category, and stop chasing a category that repeatedly stalls. That is far more useful than “we need better items.”
At Capital Benefit Auctions, I built an analytics engine to bring several years of item and bidding results into the same view. It helps me spot category trends, compare participation, and measure proceeds after costs. The tool does not decide what to procure; it gives us better questions to ask the people who know the donors.
If you are considering a consignment trip, bring those answers to the provider. “Our guests compete for nearby, flexible stays, but fixed-date trips have struggled” is a much stronger starting point than “show us your best sellers.” It lets the provider help you select an experience that fits your room.
Your auction has already collected feedback from your supporters. Before asking your committee to find more items, take the time to read it.
Karen Wrege is the founder of Capital Benefit Auctions, helping nonprofits use their event results to plan stronger auctions and fund-a-need appeals.
Subscribe to BlueTree Marketing’s newsletter for expert fundraising tips and insights, plus learn about risk-free vacation packages and experiences that will make your events memorable.