Strategic Planning for Fundraising Success: Tips & Best Practices
Fundraising isn’t just about asking for donations, it’s about inspiring people to rally behind a cause that matters. The most successful fundraisers don’t happen by chance; they’re built on thoughtful strategy, clear goals, and meaningful connection. With the right plan in place, your team stays aligned, your messaging reaches supporters at the right moment, and every touchpoint strengthens donor relationships. In this blog, discover how to set focused objectives that will cultivate lasting relationships with donors that fuel your mission long after the event ends.
Why Strategic Planning Matters For a Fundraiser
A strategic fundraising plan does more than outline revenue goals, but also aligns your financial targets directly to your mission and the impact you want to make. With a clear plan in place, you’ll understand who your donors are and what they want, what inspires them to give, and how to communicate in ways that encourage continued support. Having a strategic plan for fundraising not only helps achieve your goal, also helps your team understand their roles and responsibilities.
1. Set Clear & Measurable Objectives
The foundation of any successful strategy is about setting Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, and Time-bound (SMART) goals. To achieve your target financial goal for the fundraiser, you need to break how you’ll do this into actionable metrics. Examples of these goals include:
Donor Retention Rates⎯Instead of just focusing a number, set a goal to increase donor retention by 45%–50% year-over-year.
Acquisition Targets⎯How many new donors do you need to acquire to offset natural attrition? This number is usually 20%–30%.
Average Gift Size⎯For most small-to-midsize nonprofits, a good Average Gift Size (AGS) goal is $75–$125 for one-time donors, and $20–$40 per month for recurring donors.
Keep in mind that there isn’t one “right” number because these goals depend on your audience, cause, and fundraising channels.
2. Understanding Your Target Audience
One of the biggest mistakes nonprofits make is assuming that everyone is their audience. If you try to speak to everyone, you end up speaking to no one. Tips for targeting your audience.
Segment Your Donors: Segmenting your donors increases response rates, average gift size, and retention because people give more when messages feel personal and relevant. Donor segmentation helps you tailor messaging, timing, and ask amounts based on who someone is and how they’ve engaged with your organization.
Major Donors: These individuals require personal touches like phone calls, meetings, and impact reports. They invest in the vision, not just the immediate need.
Monthly Donors: This group values consistency, connection, and a sense of belonging. They are the foundation of your organization’s long-term sustainability, so keep them updated on your organization's news, how their impact is helping, invitations to special events, and other ways to show them you appreciate their donations.
One-Time Donors: These are your prospects for future monthly giving. Your strategy for this donor group should be centered around securing a second gift so that you can turn a one-time donor into a repeat supporter.
3. Use Data & Analytics
Analyzing data and analytics helps you predict future trends. If you know that the majority of your revenue happens in a specific month, you can strategically plan your campaigns and fundraisers leading up to this month. Things to look for in your data:
What did the last 2-3 years show for revenue?
Which campaigns had the highest ROI?
Which time of year brings in the most unsolicited gifts?
What is the drop-off rate after a first-time donation?
4. Build Strong Donor Relationships
Donors see their gift as an investment in creating a better world. Your job is to show them the return on that investment through a compelling story of impact. Don’t just say, “Thank you for your donation.” Connect the dots between their generosity and the real-world difference it made.
5. Use Digital Tools & Multi-Channel Approaches
The donor journey is rarely a straight line. A donor might see a post on social media, receive an email a week later, visit your website, and finally donate after receiving a direct mail letter. Your strategy needs to touch all different channels. Channels you should use include:
Email: This is a great medium for storytelling, urgent appeals, and direct links to donate.
Social Media: Best for brand awareness, community building, and visual proof of impact.
Direct Mail: This is still really effective, especially for older demographics.
6. Create a Donation Page
Every element of your strategic planning funnels should be directed to one place which is your donation page. If confusing or difficult to use, you risk losing the donation. Some best practice tips:
Mobile Optimization: Over half of 50% emails are opened on mobile devices. If your donation page isn't mobile-friendly, you are leaving money on the table.
One-Click Payment Options: Offer payment options like Apple Pay or Google Pay to reduce friction. The fewer fields a donor has to fill out, the higher your conversion rate will be.
7. Engage Your Board & Staff
Engaging your board and staff is critical to the success of any fundraising campaign. When everyone is aligned, motivated, and empowered, your outreach becomes far more impactful. Engaged board and staff members aren’t just participants, but they become champions for your organization to help expand your reach, boost donations, and strengthen donor trust.
Start Planning Now For Your Next Fundraiser
By setting clear objectives, understanding your audience, leveraging data, and prioritizing relationships, you’ll build a solid fundraising campaign that you can tweak every year. Another important part of planning a fundraiser is that you have enticing auction items that will generate excitement and get donors to want to bid on them. At BlueTree Marketing, we’ll help you curate an auction catalog for a live or silent fundraiser that will be tailored to what your audience is interested in. Contact us to learn more about our consignment vacation packages that will drive donor engagement and bids!
FAQs
-
Without a plan, fundraising efforts can be inconsistent and inefficient. Strategic planning helps prioritize initiatives, target the right donors, allocate resources effectively, and measure impact, all to help get to your fundraising goal.
-
It’s best to review your overall fundraising strategy annually, but assess quarterly if there needs to be any tweaks based on campaign performance, donor feedback, or changes in organizational priorities.
-
Focus on building relationships through personalized communication, multi-channel outreach, and donor stewardship. Regularly track metrics like retention rates, average gift size, and donor engagement to refine your strategy.
-
Passport to Paradise Raffles are really effective because:
They create excitement and anticipation
They offer a simple, low-barrier way to participate
Large prizes motivate higher ticket sales
They can be combined with other fundraising activities
They are a great way to reach fundraising goals because the charity makes more money
-
Add a suggested donation step directly in the checkout flow. Consider offering tiered options so supporters can choose a level that feels right for them.
-
A smooth, user-friendly checkout that reduces friction and a well-placed donation prompt taps into attendees’ excitement and willingness to give.
-
Sharing relatable stories and showing clear progress toward goals makes donors feel their contribution matters. This emotional connection can increase the likelihood and size of donations.
Subscribe to BlueTree Marketing’s newsletter for expert fundraising tips and insights, plus learn about risk-free vacation packages and experiences that will make your events memorable.